“Images are a way of writing. When you have the talent to be able to write and to draw, it seems a shame to choose one.” (Marjane Satrapi)

August is Women in Translation month, hosted by Meytal at Biblibio. Do head over to her blog to read more about WITMonth and join in!

Throughout August I’m hoping to post entirely about women in translation, and this week I’m looking at two women who are famous animators as part of their writing.

Firstly, Tove Jansson, who was the creator of the Moomins.

Jansson also wrote novels for adults and Sort Of Books have done a great job making English translations available. The True Deceiver (1982, trans. Thomas Teal 2009) is a simple, unsettling tale set over a winter in a snowbound hamlet in Finland.

Katri Kling is a young woman in her 20s who lives with her brother Mats and her nameless Alsatian dog, keeping herself to herself.

“Every night I hear the snow against the window, the soft whisper of the snow blown in form the sea, and it’s good, I wish the whole village could be covered and erased and finally be clean…Nothing can be as peaceful and endless as a long winter darkness, going on and on, like living in a tunnel where the dark sometimes deepens into night and sometimes eases to twilight, you’re screened from everything, protected, even more alone than usual.”

Meanwhile, Anna Aemelin is an animator who lives on the outskirts of the village. If Katrin seems old beyond her years, Anna has stayed somewhat infantalised despite now being quite old. She eats soft food out of tins, has a cleaner to take care of the huge house she’s lived in her whole life, and has no idea how to manage her money.

“Perhaps the reason people called Anna Aemelin nice was because nothing had ever forced her to exhibit malice, and because she had an uncommon ability to forget unpleasant things. She just shook them off and continued on her own vague but stubborn way. In fact, her spoiled benevolence was frightening, but no-one ever had time to notice.”

Katrin sets her sights on Anna’s house, and so the two women collide:

“That’s where she lives. Mats and I will live there too. But I have to wait. I need to think carefully before I give this Anna Aemelin an important place in my life.”

What follows is a study of the tense, odd relationship that these two women build together. They are both quite damaged in different ways, and they are both loners. Mats has an unspecified learning difficulty and so he operates outside of this dynamic; it is very much about the two women. Mats is Katrin’s motivation though, and they are close without communicating much to one another:

“They owned a silence together that was peaceful and straightforward.”

This is not a story for those who like dramatic events and everything explained. What Jansson does expertly is portray these two women and the development of their relationship. She is entirely unsentimental – neither woman is particularly likeable – but the quiet, suffocating way she builds the story is compulsive.

“Anna walked faster, looking only down at the road. Several neighbours passed by, but she didn’t notice their greetings, just wanted to get home, home to the dreadful Katri, to her own altered world which had grown severe but where nothing was wicked and concealed.”

I really adore Jansson’s writing. It is beautiful but not overdone; pared down to its essence, she takes an incisive look at human relationships and never wastes a word. The True Deceiver is compelling and totally believable.

Secondly, Persepolis by Marjane Satrapi (2003, trans. Anjali Singh 2004). This is a graphic novel so please bear with me as I hardly ever read graphic novels and I’ve no idea how to write about it. Set in Iran, this is one more stop on my Around the World in 80 Books Reading Challenge, hosted by Hard Book Habit.

Persepolis was made into a film in 2007 and uses the animation from the novel (it was co-written and co-directed by the author), so this trailer gives a good idea of the artwork:

Satrapi’s drawings are stark and simple in black and white and without excessive detail. As a result her images are incredibly strong and impactful, with nothing to distract from the central message each picture conveys.

The story is a powerful one. Marjane, born in 1970, grows up in tumultuous times in Iran. Her parents are liberal Marxists who allow their daughter a great deal of freedom, but after the Islamic Revolution in 1979 she has to wear a veil and be careful how she behaves in public. Young Marjane is religious and converses with God, but her favourite book is Dialectic Materialism where Marx and Descartes debate the meaning of the material world. “It was funny to see how much Marx and God looked liked each other. Though Marx’ hair was a bit curlier.”

Marjane learns about the history of her country and her family, having descended from Iran’s last emperor. Western culture appeals, while at the same time she knows that Britain conspired with the CIA in 1953 to depose Mossadeq after he nationalised the oil industry, to return the Shah to power (side note: when our previous Prime Minister Tony Blair was busy starting illegal wars in the Middle East, he had to be told who Mossadeq was, because he couldn’t understand Iranian hostility to Britain. I don’t even know where to begin with that.)

Her beloved uncle Anoosh is arrested and asks to Marjane for a final visit before he is executed. The scene where he holds her and calls her “Star of my Life” I found so moving. You can view it on Pintrest here (it’s really hard to write about a graphic novel without images! But I’m worried about copyright infringement ☹)

Persepolis follows Marjane as she leaves Iran for Austria, and her return four years later. We see her growing up, meeting boys, trying drugs, going to parties. She struggles to accept herself, feeling too Persian in Europe and too European in Iran. At times she loses her way, but always returns to her grandmother’s advice:

“There is nothing worse than bitterness and vengeance…always keep your dignity and be true to yourself.”

Persepolis covers absolutely massive themes and is a remarkable achievement. International politics, religion, feminism, identity, social responsibility, extremism, idealism, familial love, are all here. The fact that it’s in graphic novel form mean that it never feels a heavy read and yet Persepolis doesn’t pull its punches or aim to make difficult truths easy for the reader. I’ve not remotely done it justice here.

To end, Marjane loves her hard-won Kim Wilde tape. Here’s the lovely lady herself aged 20, making her TOTP debut:

33 thoughts on ““Images are a way of writing. When you have the talent to be able to write and to draw, it seems a shame to choose one.” (Marjane Satrapi)

  1. Great choices for WIT Month! While I love the film of Persepolis, I’ve never actually read the book itself – maybe I should remedy that at some point. I sometimes wonder if it’s easier for the audience to engage with powerful stories like this when they’re presented in graphic or animated format? The film Waltzing with Bashir could be another example of this…and the graphic novel Maus, of course.

    Liked by 1 person

    • Thanks Jacqui! The book is very readable and if you liked the film I think you’ll like it.

      I think it is easier to engage with terrible things in a graphic/animated format, but the balance has to be right to not let the reader off the hook. Satrapi manages this brilliantly.

      I really liked Waltzing with Bashir but I’ve not seen Maus – I’ll look out for it.

      Like

  2. Oh, I loved the Moomins and also read The Summer Book which I enjoyed. I saw the film of Persepolis but didn’t read the book. I like graphic novels more and more and was interested that one got long listed for the Booker.

    Liked by 1 person

  3. WIT sounds like such an amazing concept! And I cannot wait to read Persepolis; I’m so glad you chose that as one of the books- I’ve heard only absolutely great things about it!

    Liked by 1 person

  4. I love Kim Wilde. A lot. Every time I go to the hairdresser and they ask how I want my hair blow-dried I say “Like Kim Wilde”. Obviously all hair dressers are about 12-years-old so this means nothing to them. Or rather, it once meant nothing to them. I have now introduced a new generation to the brilliance of Kim.

    I’m not sure how but Moomins completely bypassed my childhood – perhaps they weren’t big in Australia? When my own kids were little they were ‘relaunched’ but I kept wondering where I was the first time around! Busy watching the Wombles. perhaps…

    Liked by 1 person

    • That is so good to hear that you are educating the next generation in this vital issue – I am very impressed! I was thinking only yesterday about how I’ve never really liked my hair super-groomed looking, and I suddenly realised it can be traced back to my childhood love of Bananarama 😀

      The Wombles would be a very good use of your childhood time! Although the Moomins were popular here, they are absolutely *massive* in Scandinavia – I have a Danish friend who is devoted to them to this day. Bagpuss and The Flumps were my personal favourites 🙂

      Like

  5. I read The True Deceiver about six years ago on Sarah’s recommendation, and think I’l get it out again so I can dream of colder times and places. I have a friend who has a substantial Moomin phobia, especially the fuzzy felt ones of the animated TV show which seem to have triggered it, although they were a bit weird so I can see where he’s coming from 😉
    And I will definitely get Persepolis, I love a graphic novel and seem to remember them in a different, deep way, like when connecting with any art I suppose, the images and story spans the dimensions (and can make children scared of Moomins).

    Liked by 1 person

    • The True Deceiver will definitely give you weather envy – being snowed in sounds pretty blissful right now!

      Much as I think the Moomins are adorable, I can see how they could trigger a phobia- they’re definitely odd…

      Persepolis is so brilliant, I really hope you enjoy it. The powerful story and striking images work perfectly together and enhance what is being said, rather than detract from it. As you say, this makes it really memorable. I look forward to hearing what you make of it!

      Liked by 1 person

  6. For once, your post hasn’t added to increased book spending on my part, but only because I already have both of these! Such great picks for WITmonth – so different, but both brilliant.

    Liked by 1 person

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.