Novella a Day in May 2020 #29

The Birds on the Trees – Nina Bawden (1970) 196 pages

The Birds on the Trees was sent to me a long while ago now, by the lovely Ali at heavanali. Ali’s a great advocate for Bawden’s writing and it was her enthusiasm that got me picking up one of my favourite childhood authors again as an adult. I’ve really enjoyed the Bawden I’ve read so far and The Birds on the Trees was no exception.

The story concerns the very ordinary middle-class Flowers family and what happens when the eldest son Toby experiences mental health problems.

He is kicked out of school for smoking drugs and returns home refusing to follow his parents wishes to attend a crammer in order to sit his Oxford entrance exam. His hair needs a cut and he’s not washing. He’s spending a lot of time dressed in a burnouse. His parents Maggie and Charles are at a complete loss as to what to do.

“Now, for the first time (their first, real crisis?) he saw what drove her was something more like fear: she raced through life as over marshy ground, fearing to stand still in case she sank in quagmire.”

This all sounds pretty mild but we never really find out what’s going on with Toby. He’s diagnosed with schizophrenia but this is questioned by a family friend and doctor, who thinks Toby has drug-induced psychosis. In a prologue we see Toby as a small child telling neighbours he’s been abandoned by his parents at Christmas, that they don’t feed him, and then later that his parents are dead. Clearly something’s wrong, but Bawden never offers trite answers as to what that might be – was Toby always unwell? Was he neglected in some way?

Very little of Toby’s speech – and never his thoughts – are provided to the reader. The Birds on the Trees is a study of a family under immense strain, but the family member who’s instigated the crisis remains remote. This is a masterstroke as it keeps us in a similar position to his family: at a loss as to why things are unravelling so considerably.

One of the rare times we hear from Toby is when he’s trying to impress potential girlfriend Hermia, and the fantasy, arrogance and pretension of what he says just brought home his youth to me:

“‘I have left school. But I haven’t made up my mind. Eventually, I expect, I shall go into something interesting and creative, like publishing or films. Or perhaps the theatre, though the standard’s so terrifying low at the moment, one would have to be careful. I mean, it would be so easy to write a play just for commercial success, one would have to watch out that one wasn’t corrupted.”

The family are distant from each other, but in a very ordinary way. Maggie and Charles take their frustrations out on each other, middle child Lucy starts stealing and youngest Greg is convinced he’s adopted. At one point Lucy attacks her aunt with grape scissors, which I again thought hinted at something deeper troubling this family, but it’s not clear. Maggie’s mother can’t see what all the fuss is about:

“ ‘I never heard of such a thing,’ Sara Evans said. ‘Taking a boy to a psychiatrist because he refuses to have his haircut!’”

I really enjoyed the portraits of the rest of the Flowers family, which were so well-observed, both psychologically – as I would expect from Bawden – and physically:

“The skin on his face was loose and baggy: he was always folding and pleating it as if it was an ill-fitting garment he happened to be wearing.”

 Toby deteriorates and although fears about heroin addiction prove ill-founded, he cannot get out of bed. He is hospitalised and treated with ECT, which would be practically unheard of now. Although the treatment of Toby has dated, and to some extent the attitudes of the family, I thought this novel hadn’t dated nearly as badly as it could have done. This is because Bawden is so good at characterisation and so psychologically astute that the examination of these people under pressure, both individually and as a family, remains fresh.

I read a review from when The Birds on the Trees was nominated for the Lost Man Booker Prize that criticised the novel for being too optimistic in its ending. Maybe I’m just a miserable so-and-so but I didn’t think it was that optimistic. I thought it was one character allowing a brief moment of hope, when the reader knows things are unlikely to get any easier…

“How could you ever really understand why people behaved as they did? Oh, you could guess…but it was like trying to find your way through some intricate underworld of caverns and passages by the light of one flickering match!

22 thoughts on “Novella a Day in May 2020 #29

  1. This sounds such a powerful understated portrayal of how the mental health problems of one family member effect them all. I see it was published in 1970 when such issues were not as openly discussed as they are now.

    Liked by 1 person

    • It does show very clearly the ramifications on a largely bewildered family. It is understated, definitely not melodramatic. We have come a long way in 50 years. There’s still so much to do around understanding mental health and reducing stigma though.

      Liked by 1 person

  2. I was stunned to discover Nina Bawden’s adult books. I had read her children’s books at teachers’ college, but didn’t have access to her novels until I stumbled on four of them on a remainder table. She is just brilliant, IMO.

    Liked by 1 person

  3. This is one of my favourite Bawden novels, so I am delighted you liked it. I think she writes about family so well. I think there is an element of Toby’s character that is based on her own son, he took his own life.

    Liked by 1 person

  4. That haircut comment is so simple and yet so powerful. How differently we view things from inside and outside situations where we’ve little experience (and little imagination?) about how life is for other people. I’ve only read a couple of her adult books too (like you, I loved some of her children’s books) and am looking forward to reading more. She’s such an astute observer.

    Liked by 1 person

  5. I’ve read a Bawden but must admit I did struggle with it. She writes well, and captures place and character, but parts of the plot of the one I read didn’t hang together. I considered trying other ones then I think sent some volumes to Ali! I guess we can’t all like the same books!

    Liked by 1 person

  6. I read this book a few years back when it was nominated for the Lost Booker that you mention and really enjoyed its portrait of domestic life in a more socially restrictive time and place where keeping up appearances was so important. Thanks for reminding me about this very powerful novella.

    Liked by 1 person

  7. I suspect the poor lad had just been in lockdown for several weeks. No haircut and I assure you, if I had a burnouse, I’d be wearing it by now. And if it goes on much longer, I suspect I may well need ECT to revivify my mind… 😉

    Liked by 1 person

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.