I really want to increase my blogging in 2023 – as I’m an incredibly strong-willed person who always achieves any goal they set, I have absolutely no doubt I will achieve this aim 😀
Anyway, the wonderful reading events that take place are always an incentive to help me on my way, and in January Annabel runs her enticing Nordic FINDS month.
This meant that I have finally pulled a book from the TBR that has been languishing there for years: The Visit of the Royal Physician by Swedish author Per Olov Enquist (1999 trans. Tiina Nunnally 2001). A historical novel set in the 18th-century Danish courts, it tells the story of King Christian VII’s mental ill health, his marriage to Caroline Mathilde (sister to George III) and her affair with the titular German doctor, Johann Friedrich Struensee.
TVOTRP is hugely lauded, winning the August prize and the Independent Foreign Fiction Prize. This meant I went in with unfairly high expectations and at first I wasn’t sure this novel was for me. I suppose TVOTRP would be classed as a documentary novel, and initially I found this style distancing. However, by the end I was very much involved in this sad tale of people sacrificed to political power struggles where there is no room for humanity.
Even if the historical events are unfamiliar, the reader knows it will end with the execution of Struensee, as this is where the novel begins. We’re then taken back to his arrival at court, a man of the Enlightenment, viewed with some degree of suspicion by those resistant to change.
King Frederik V dies in his forties, and there is a vivid scene of him on his deathbed with his son, being abusive until the end. Christian is sixteen when he becomes King Christian VII and he is already struggling to comprehend reality.
“Christian explained, in a stubborn attempt to make sense of things, that he understood the court to be a theatre, that he had to learn his lines, and that he would be punished if he didn’t know them by heart.”
But was he one person or two?”
Enquist demonstrates so clearly that it would be some sort miracle if Christian managed to stay well in the environment of the court. He is not only abused by his family but by the courtiers; he is physically and mentally tortured.
Caroline Mathilde is 15 when they marry.
“Afterwards everyone agreed that it was unfortunate that she did indeed have talents. If the proper assessment had been made from the outset, namely that she possessed some talents, then the entire catastrophe might have been averted.
But no one could have predicted this.”
These teenagers are not expected to rule Denmark. They are expected to be figureheads and provide heirs, and not get in the way of the power-hungry politicians that surround them. When Struensee arrives in court, he poses a huge threat despite not appearing to want power at all. Firstly, he genuinely cares about Christian:
“It was understood that something had happened. The German doctor with the blonde hair, the quick but wary smile and the kindly eyes, had become somebody. Since he had no title and could not be placed within a precise hierarchy, this caused uneasiness.
Attempts were made to decipher him. He was not easy to decipher. He was friendly, discreet, and refused to make use of his power, or at least what was considered to be power.
People didn’t understand him.”
Secondly, he is a man of the Enlightenment, deeply threatening to Puritan courtiers like the advisor Guldberg, who is slowly growing his influence. Thirdly, he sleeps with the Queen:
“Christian, Caroline Mathilde, Struensee. Those three.
They seem to be observing each other with curiosity and suspicion. The court observed them too. As they observed the court. Everyone seemed to be waiting.”
The tension builds as the reader knows this situation will absolutely not be tolerated. And it seems such a travesty. The King is happy and cared for; the Queen is happy and fulfilled; the person taking decisions on behalf of the ruler is progressive, liberal, and trying to improve the situation of the masses. Why not let it continue?
Struensee is not naïve and he is filled with a sense of foreboding. Meanwhile, Caroline Mathilde seems to believe they can outwit the malevolent forces that are closing in…
“Her analysis surprised him.
He thought that her extremely lucid, extremely brutal view of the mechanisms of power had been born at the English court. No, she told him, I lived in a cloister. Then where had she learned all this? She was not one of those that Brandt, with some scorn, used to call ‘the female schemers’.
Struensee understood that she saw a different kind of pattern to his.”
The style of TVOTRP is really interesting. As I mentioned earlier, it’s a documentary style, but with an omniscient narrator so there is space given to the feelings and motivations of all the characters. The sentences are generally choppy, but often also poetic. Enquist balances these opposing approaches expertly. I never quite got past that initial distance I felt and so this stopped me absolutely loving the novel, but I did think it was an excellent and compassionate exploration of the pressures of public life and the dangers for those trying to change entrenched power structures.
Although not a depressing novel, it did seem desperately sad, for all concerned.
“The revolution that Struensee initiated was quickly stopped. It took only a few weeks for everything to revert to the way it was before, or to even earlier times. It was as if his 632 decrees, issued during the two years known as the ‘Struensee era’ were paper swallows, some which landed, while others were still hovering low over the surface of the field and hadn’t yet managed to alight on the Danish landscape.”
To end, I saw A Royal Affair (which tells the same story but isn’t an adaptation of this novel) when it came out in 2012. I don’t remember much of it now but I do remember enjoying it and thinking all three leads were excellent. From this trailer I would say Christian is portrayed less sympathetically than Enquist saw him, but it definitely looks worth a re-watch:
What a curse to be born into a royal family! At least the modern Danish version is an improvement.
LikeLiked by 1 person
It’s definitely not a life I would want at all!
LikeLiked by 1 person
I’m glad you are planning to blog more in 2023. It’s lovely that you have pulled a book out of your TBR to join in an event in the community.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Thanks Deb! The bookish community are great so I do want to be a more active member 😊
LikeLike
The story itself sounds fascinating, Madame B, and sounds like tales I’ve read about what it was like back in the day in the Russian royal family. And I do wonder if expectations are entirely different nowadays – but that’s another matter. Interesting re the style though – the quotations you share do get across what you say about that distancing effect and it’s a shame, because a story like this would really need to involve the reader to be entirely successful.
LikeLiked by 1 person
I’m glad you thought the quotes got that across Kaggsy. It was still a really compelling story, because as you say it’s fascinating. But I didn’t feel entirely involved with the characters as people. And yes – if recent media stories are to be believed, it is questionable how much has really changed!
LikeLiked by 1 person
Ah, for the good old days, when execution was the solution to Royal problems! I feel we should bring that back. 😉
LikeLiked by 3 people
🤣🤣🤣
LikeLiked by 1 person
Thank you so much for joining in with #NordicFINDS23. Much appreciated, and you found what sounds like a fascinating book to read.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Thanks for hosting it Annabel, and for the prompt to finally pick this novel up!
LikeLike
A good choice for NordicFinds and an evocative review. I’m glad you enjoyed the revelations even though the style prevented the usual enjoyment one gets from a literary immersion.
Wonderful to have you back blogging, your contributions and support to the blogging community are much appreciated.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Thank you for your kind comment Claire, much appreciated!
LikeLike
I wasn’t aware of Nordic FINDS! thank you! I have a crime fiction book from Finland on the shelf.
This sounds like a fascinating read about a part of history I know nothing about.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Wonderful! I’ll look forward to your Nordic FINDS review.
It’s such an interesting period of history, I’d love to learn more about it.
LikeLike
This sounds like the type of book that makes you very glad to be living in the here and now! Can you imagine being married to a mad king at the age of 15?!
The movie looks intense!
LikeLiked by 1 person
I know – thank goodness I’m not an eighteenth century princess, far too stressful!
I don’t remember much about the film, but it’s a pretty intense story for sure.
LikeLiked by 1 person
This made waves when it came out in Germany ages ago and so I suspect it’s in my piles. It sounds very interesting and tragic. I’m currently learning Swedish which is close to Danish and Norwegian and think what you call choppy might really be a translation very close to the original. In some ways these languages flow very differently from English or even German.
I’m glad you too are back. Maybe we’ll share a post a day in May extravaganza later this year. 😁
LikeLiked by 1 person
Ah, that’s interesting, thanks Caroline. I’ve not noticed it with other translations from those languages but as you say, maybe they decided to try and stay closer to the original. How exciting to be learning Swedish! I hope it’s going well.
I hoping for daily May post although I never feel I have it in me 😁 It will be great if you’re there too, definitely encouraging!
LikeLiked by 1 person
I’m really enjoying it so far.
I hope we can cheer each other on. It’s a huge undertaking but I remember liking it a great deal.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Glad to hear you’re planning to blog more again. I am being more erratic these days, and constantly playing catch up with blog reading too.
Anyway this historical novel does sound fascinating, a very colourful period in Danish history that I knew nothing about. I don’t think I would have wanted to be part of that family.
LikeLiked by 1 person
That’s the plan Ali, but we’ll see! I’m always catching up with blog reading too 🙂 It is such a fascinating period, and yes, definitely a family best observed from afar! Being married into it while still a teenager and moving abroad away from everything you know must have been overwhelming.
LikeLike
A Royal Affair looks terrific – but of course it’s on the only streaming service I don’t have! So perhaps will seek out this book instead.
LikeLiked by 1 person
I do remember it as being very good. What a pain you can’t get it! I hope you enjoy the book & that the film turns up on one of your services soon.
LikeLike